This post contains affiliate links. Affilate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network. The site may earn a commission when affiliate link clicks result in a purchase. Read the full disclosure here.

Kadarius Toney Rookie Card First Look (Buyer’s Guide & Pricing)

Kadarius Toney Rookie Card eBay Listings

kadarius toney rookie card


Twas a slow start for Kadarius Toney, but suddenly things are looking up. If and his on-the-field performance is going that direction, it’s only a matter of time before the Kadarius Toney rookie card market follows suit. So all of you who were scared about the fact that he’s a Giant may need to consider your position on this talented young wideout. Worried that the slow start is more pf a representation of what Toney is than that 185-yard breakout game at Dallas? Don’t be. Toney was also a slow starter in college!


Inside Kadarius Toney’s College Performance


If it wasn’t for a senior year that had scouts drooling, the thought of a Kadarius Toney rookie card might be nothing more than an afterthought. Yes, you could definitely call the kid a late-bloomer. In spite of the fact that he played four years in college, Toney’s potential wouldn’t truly be realized until his senior year as a wide receiver for the Florida Gators. That year, Toney had 70 receptions for 984 yards and 10 receiving touchdowns. Additionally, he ran 19 times for 161 yards and a rushing touchdown. One statistic that definitely stands out is the fact that Toney got a lot of yards out of every catch as Toney averaged a whopping 13.3 yards per catch for his college career. Something that played a part in his 984 yard total being the third-highest among receivers in the SEC.

Once the slow start was past him, Kadarius Toney had games in which he made a name for himself. For instance, in a 38-17 Florida win against Vanderbilt, Toney had 6 receptions for 107 yards and 1 touchdown. In another SEC game against Tennessee, Toney had 8 receptions for 108 yards and 1 touchdown. While those performances helped put wins on the record, Toney’s greatest games would come in contests where his team lost. Nevertheless, they are worth mentioning. For example, in a Florida loss to LSU by a score of 37-34, Toney had 9 receptions for 182 yards and 1 touchdown. He also had 56 rushing yards on the ground. Safe to say Toney did his part. Likewise, in a loss to Alabama by a final score of 52-46 in the 2020 SEC Championship game, Toney had a monster game with 8 receptions for 153 yards. While these performances didn’t bring the Ws, they definitely captured the attention of NFL scouts.

Now that Toney is in the NFL, the same scouts that played a role of making him a first-round draft pick are looking to be validated. A couple of more games like that one in Dallas and they soon will be. Here are a few Kadarius Toney rookie card options that you’ll want to own if he meets those expectations.



Break Out Rookie Alert: Ja’Marr Chase Rookie Card Review



Kadarius Toney Rookie Card First Look


2021 Panini Gold Standard (Check eBay Listings)

kadarius toney rookie card

Let’s start with Kadarius in that fresh Giants jersey. These are just about the most expensive Kadarius Toney rookie cards you’ll find right now with numerous options worth more than $250. And if you really wanna get nuts see if you can track down that lucky guy who owns the 1/1 NFL Shield autograph card. You’ll likely need close to $1,000 if you want to convince him to sell.


2021 Panini Prizm Draft (Check eBay Listings)

Nothing but great options here. The Prizm varieties come with Toney’s autograph and are going for much less than some of the other high octane first round draft picks from 2021. We love the Red Pulsar and Mojo Refractors. Autograph and a serial number of 25 or less and still only $100? All day.


2021 Mosaic Draft (Check eBay Listings)

Right now the options available with Toney’s autograph are hogging the spotlight. Look for the Scripts insert or a card from the Rookie Autographs line if you have a hankering for some ink. However, autographed cards aren’t the only thing Mosaic has to offer. There are plenty of rare Prizm options at incredibly affordable prices. A go to set for that perfect mixture of quality and affordability.


2021 Panini Certified

certified kadarius toney rookie card

Simply put, one of the best collections for a Kadarius Toney rookie card you’ll come across so far. Whether it’s an autograph, material card, or both, Certified has all the boxes checked. The card above is a Freshmen Fabrics autograph with a print run of just 10. While this is one of the more expensive options in the set, there are plenty of inserts and base card options that are more suitable for the casual collector.



Related Content:  Jaylen Waddle Rookie Card Top Picks



Kadarius Toney Rookie Card Investment Strategy


Short (1 year or less)

Let’s face it, even the rarest autographed Kadarius Toney rookie card options aren’t going to do much damage to your bankroll. At the moment, anyways. He has the potential to be one of the biggest impact players of the 2021 rookie class was starting to turn the corner before the recent ankle injury. It doesn’t appear to serious so consider picking one up if there is any lull in the market. 7/10


Medium (1 to 3 years)

Even with the breakout game against the Cowboy, Toney remains a high-risk high-reward player. If you plan on buying be prepared to hold for more than a year if need be. The talent is there. Let’s see how long before he puts it together on a conisistent basis. 7/10


Long (3 years or more)