This post contains affiliate links. Affilate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network. The site may earn a commission when affiliate link clicks result in a purchase. Read the full disclosure here.

Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card Market: Room to Grow?

Find Your Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card Bargain on eBay!

Patrick Mahomes rookie card National Treasures


When thinking about buying a Patrick Mahomes rookie card, the first thing you should consider is growth. Whether it be short or long term, the market’s ability to grow should always be at the top of your thoughts. When it comes to short and long with Patrick Mahomes, both seem like good options. But which is the better strategy? We’ll give our two cents on the matter here it a bit. But before we go into that, let’s sum up what Mahomes has done to build his rookie card market to the astronomical levels it’s currently sitting at.


Patrick Mahomes:  The Story So Far


When we think of the greatest quarterback in football history, a few names come to mind: Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Drew Brees, Rich Gannon.  Okay, Gannon was a weak attempt at humor.  We hope that was apparent enough but you never know! At any rate, there’s no question these three are some of the best to ever play in the National Football League. Don’t look now, but it seems there could be a forth on that list in the near future.

That player is Patrick Mahomes. The Kansas City Chiefs quarterback may only be 25 but if his trend continues, you’ll soon find it hard to leave the name Mahomes out of that conversation. For instance, Mahomes is the fastest player to reach 10,000 yards passing in NFL history. Additionally, he’s already got a Super Bowl ring along with a couple of MVP awards (regular season and Super Bowl). And let’s not forget the First-Team All-Pro selection, NFL Offensive Player of the Year nod, and two Pro Bowl selections. Let that sink in.

In his first season as a starting QB, Mahomes threw 50 touchdowns with just 12 interceptions. Those 50 TDs were good for the league lead just like his 5,097 passing yards and 8.8 yards per attempt. And the only season he hasn’t won a Super Bowl, he was still able to take his team to the AFC title game before losing to the eventual champions (New England Patriots). All of this leads us to believe that Mahomes will be a star for many years to come. But does that make a Patrick Mahomes rookie card play a slam dunk? Yes and no. We’ll explain but let’s check out some cards we have our eyes on.



Alert: Some of the cards you’re about to see can be INCREDIBLY valuable. But how do they compare to the big NFL cards from the 80s? Find out in our most valuable football cards of the 1980s list!.



Our Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card Hot List



2017 Panini Prizm (Buy it on eBay)

Patrick Mahomes rookie card prizm

Easily one of the most sought-after Patrick Mahomes cards. This card features Mahomes in his Kansas City Chiefs home uniform and of course, has that look we’ve come to expect from Prizm. And what we mean by that is ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL. If you can find one of these for a good price, we suggest looking into it!


2017 Panini Origins (Buy this Patrick Mahomes rookie card on eBay)

Panini Origins

This particular card features Mahomes donning a 00 jersey in front of a red and yellow background. However, there are plenty of different variations with a wide range of values. So whether you’re a big spender or a cautious newcomer, Panini Origins offers something for all Patrick Mahomes rookie card market investors. The card is simple, elegant, and has an overall clean look.


2017 Panini Contenders (Like it? Find it on eBay!)


While the prices on some of the rarest from the set are through the roof, there are plenty out there that are more affordable. So just like the Origins set, Panini Contenders attracts a wide range of investors. And there’s also a wide array of cards. Fancy horizontal card? No problem. Like your cards with autographs? This set has that too. Overall just a well-rounded set of football cards.


2017 National Treasures (Buy on eBay)

National Treasures

If you’re looking for some of the most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards options, this set is the one you need to be focused on.  Most of the ridiculously valuable variations are laid out in a horizontal format, but you’ll be able to find the occasional vertical oddball.  A great set to consider if you’re considering a long term investment.



Honorable Mention: Patrick Mahomes Leaf Rookie Card Collection

Patrick Mahomes Leaf rookie card

Let’s face it, many cards from the sets we’ve already mentioned aren’t suitable for the casual collector. Sure, all of the sets have some Patrick Mahomes rookie cards you can pick up on the cheap. BUT, those are the most basic of basic. Now Leaf, on the other hand, offers some Mahomes rookie options that are both rare AND affordable. For instance, the Leaf Patrick Mahomes Prized Purple card sold for under $1,000 around the start of the 2020 season. It was also 1 of only 5 made with NONE GRADED HIGHER. So if you don’t want to pay the absurd dollars for a Patrick Mahomes rookie card, turn to Leaf!



Rookie cards trending now!

Tua Tagovailoa rookie card options

Kyler Murray first-year cards

Justin Herbert rookie card first take



Patrick Mahomes Draft Card Options (Buy on eBay)

patrick mahomes draft card

In addition to the Patrick Mahomes Draft card above, you can find in a variety of other sets. For instance, the card shown above is from the obscure (and under-appreciated) 2017 Sage Hit set. While obscure, its value is nothing to laugh at with recent sales prices approaching $2,000.

And that’s not the only set that offers a Draft card edition. Panini Contenders, one of the sets we’ve already covered, offers a variety of Patrick Mahomes cards where he’s wearing his college game day get up. And just like the Sage Hit set, this one offers many that close in on that $2,000 mark.



See where Patrick Mahomes placed in our 2020 NFL MVP Predictions Round Robin Tourney!



Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card Investment Strategy


Short Term

The Chiefs are great again and it Mahomes looks like he hasn’t missed a beat. Meaning there could easily be a 2nd MVP or Super Bowl in the future.  However, Mahomes and the Chiefs have such high expectations at this point that anything less than a repeat could limit your short term profits. That and only that is why this isn’t a perfect 10 for us. 9/10


Medium Term

We really like this option. And that may be an understatement. Mahomes is in a system he has become familiar with and has an offense loaded with talent. On top of that, he’s WINNING once again and many think the 2021 Super Bowl is the Chiefs to lose. So whether he wins his second Super Bowl this year or next, it seems like it’s inevitable. We love the odds of it happening within the medium-term time frame. 9.5/10


Long Term

We rarely like a long-term investment on such a young player but it’s different with Mahomes. Right now it looks like Mahomes will be the top quarterback in this league for a long time to come (although guys like Burrow and Herbert seem poised to give him a run for his money). And if that’s the case, who knows how many championships are on the way. Can he challenge Brady for Super Bowl titles by the time it’s all said and done? Quite possible. We’ve never seen a quarterback accomplish so much this earlier in his career which makes us incredibly confident in the long-term Patrick Mahomes rookie card market. 10/10